In February 2017 an emergency spillway evacuation emptied much of this valley for two days. No flood reached the city, but a house left locked with nobody in it can still go wrong quietly. This guide is the walk-through for the hour after you get the door open again.
Key takeaways
- Butte County's sheriff ordered evacuations at about 4:20 p.m. on February 12, 2017, over erosion at the Oroville emergency spillway.
- Reports put the total at about 188,000 people, with the Yuba City figure given variously as 65,000 to 76,000 and Marysville at about 12,000.
- Orders remained in place through February 13 even after water stopped going over the emergency spillway, and no flood reached the city.
- A leak that starts in an empty house runs until somebody comes home, which is the whole difference between a mop and a scope of work.
- Check the meter before you check the rooms: a dial turning with every fixture closed is the fastest sign of an active leak.
- Smell, warped trim and a soft patch of flooring are the three things people notice first and dismiss most often.
What happened in February 2017?
Erosion at the Oroville emergency spillway raised the possibility of a failure, and Butte County's sheriff ordered evacuations at about 4:20 p.m. on February 12, 2017. Yuba City and Marysville were placed under mandatory orders. Reports put the total at about 188,000 people across the affected counties.
Counts by town vary with the source, which is normal for an order issued in an afternoon and carried out in an evening. Wire service and television reporting at the time gave the Yuba City figure as anywhere from 65,000 to 76,000 and Marysville at about 12,000. Orders remained in place through the following day even after water had stopped going over the emergency spillway.
The important part of the record is what did not happen. The crisis concerned the possibility of a failure, and no flood water reached the city. Anybody who tells you otherwise is selling something. What it did produce was tens of thousands of houses locked and unattended for two days in the middle of the wet season, which is a different hazard entirely.
Why does an empty house matter at all?
Because the thing that limits most interior water losses is a person noticing. A supply line that fails while somebody is home gets a valve closed in minutes. The same failure in a locked house runs for as long as the house stays locked, and the water has nowhere to be but in the building.
An ordinary quarter-inch icemaker or toilet supply line moving water continuously will wet far more than a floor. It will find the lowest path, run under walls into rooms that look untouched, soak the base of cabinets and, on a raised floor, drop into the space beneath. Nothing about that is dramatic while it happens; it is simply uninterrupted.
There is a second mechanism that has nothing to do with plumbing. A house closed up with no air moving through it holds whatever moisture was already in it, and a small ongoing leak that would have evaporated away in a lived-in room instead raises the damp in a closed cupboard. That is why the nose is a genuinely useful instrument on the way back in.
What do you do before you go past the hallway?
Stop and use your senses, then find the meter. Listen for running water. Smell for damp. Look at the hallway floor along the walls. Then go outside to the water meter, close every fixture in the house first, and watch whether the dial is still moving.
The meter test is the single most useful thing you can do in the first ten minutes, and it needs no tools. With nothing running inside, a dial or digit that keeps turning means water is leaving the pipe somewhere between the meter and a fixture. If it is turning, close the main at the meter or at the house valve and leave it closed until you know where the water is going.
Power deserves the same caution it would during a live leak. Do not walk into standing water in a room with outlets at floor level or with a panel on the wall, and do not reach for a switch with wet hands or wet feet. If there is water across a floor and you cannot confirm the circuit is off, the right move is to stay in the doorway and make a call.
Which rooms go wrong first?
The ones with connections behind something: under the kitchen sink, behind the dishwasher and the refrigerator, in the laundry, at the toilet supply and at the water heater. Those six places account for most of what a crew finds when a house has been empty.
Open each cabinet and put a hand on the back and the base, not just the shelf. Particleboard that has taken water swells and turns soft at the corners before it stains, so touch tells you earlier than sight. Pull the washer forward far enough to see the floor behind it and look at the pan under the heater, where a slow weep leaves a ring rather than a puddle.
The water heater is the one worth a careful look if it sits in a garage, as many do in valley tract homes. A tank that gave way while the house was shut sends water across a slab and into the wall behind it, and the drywall wicks it upward out of sight. The sequence from there is set out on the water heater leak damage page.
What about the things that go wrong because nobody was there?
Drain traps can dry out and let sewer gas into a room. A refrigerator that lost power leaves water and spoiled food. A freezer that thawed and refroze can have leaked onto the floor behind it. None of these is structural, but each produces a smell that gets blamed on something else.
Run every tap and flush every toilet for a minute when you get back, which refills the traps and clears the standing water in the lines. If a bathroom smelled of sewer when you walked in and smells of nothing an hour after that, the trap was the answer and there is no plumbing problem to chase.
The appliance that most often causes a real loss is the refrigerator, because its water line is a connection behind a heavy object that nobody moves. Melt water on a hard floor spreads under the cabinet run beside it and under a laminate floor, where it stays. The signs of that are covered under appliance leak damage.
How long does damp take to become a mold question?
Days rather than weeks. Mold needs moisture, something organic to grow on and time, and the paper facing of wallboard supplies two of the three. A house that was wet for two days and then opened up is in better shape than one that stayed closed for a fortnight.
This is the honest reason to do the walk-through on the day you get back rather than at the weekend. Drying material that has been wet for two days is a straightforward job. Drying the same material after a fortnight behind a closed door often means cutting it out instead, because growth has had time to get into the facing and the insulation behind it.
If you find a soft patch, a musty cupboard or a stain that was not there before, open windows, get air moving and leave the material where it is. Do not paint over a stain and do not seal a cupboard up; both hide the evidence an insurer will ask for. What happens after that is described under mold after water damage.
What does the walk-through look like in order?
Outside first, then the meter, then room by room from the entrance, with the utility spaces last because they take longest. The table sets it out in the order a technician would use, and it works just as well with a flashlight and a notebook.
Write what you find as you go, with the time and the room, and photograph each item from the doorway before you touch anything. The photographs are worth more than a description later, and they take seconds while you are standing there anyway.
If the crawl space or the raised floor under an older home has water in it, treat that as its own job rather than as part of the room above. The reasons are set out under crawl space moisture, and they come down to the fact that a floor dried from above over a soaked substructure does not stay dry.
| Step | What you are looking for | What it means if you find it |
|---|---|---|
| Outside walls and vents | Damp staining low on the wall, a wet crawl space vent | Water from outside, or from a leak draining out |
| Water meter, all fixtures closed | Any movement in the dial or digits | An active leak between the meter and a fixture |
| Entry and hallways | Cupping, soft spots and dark edges along the baseboard | Water that traveled from somewhere else |
| Kitchen and laundry | Soft cabinet bases, rings on the floor, a damp wall behind an appliance | A supply or drain connection that failed |
| Bathrooms | Sewer smell, a loose toilet base, a stained ceiling below | A dry trap, or a supply leak under the floor |
| Garage and water heater | Water across the slab, a ring in the pan, a wicking wall | A tank or fitting that let go unattended |
| Crawl space or raised floor | Standing water, wet insulation hanging down | Water draining from above, or groundwater |
When is this a phone call rather than a mop?
When the meter is moving, when a floor is soft underfoot, when a wall reads damp above the baseboard, when a ceiling is stained or sagging, or when you can smell damp in a room you cannot find a source for. Any one of those is more than a towel problem.
The reason to call rather than dry it yourself is not the surface, it is the cavity. Household fans move air across a floor; they do not pull water out of the inside of a wall or out of a subfloor, and a surface that feels dry over a wet bay will fool anyone. Meters settle it in a few minutes and cost nothing to have read.
Water emergencies are answered at any hour on (833) 490-5225, and a crew is sent as soon as one is available, with no arrival time promised. Say on the call how long the house was empty, because that single fact changes what a technician expects to find and how much of the wall is likely to come open.
Frequently asked questions
Did the 2017 spillway crisis flood Yuba City?
No. The orders were issued as a precaution because of erosion at the emergency spillway and the possibility of a failure, and no flood water reached the city. Orders stayed in place through February 13 even after flow over the emergency spillway stopped. Anything beyond that is not on the record.
Why do the evacuation numbers differ?
Because they were counted during an evacuation and reported by several organizations at once. The total is given as about 188,000 people across the counties affected, the Yuba City figure as somewhere between 65,000 and 76,000 and Marysville at about 12,000. The range is what the record supports.
Should I shut the water off before I leave next time?
Closing the main at the house valve is a reasonable step if you are going to be away during an order, and it removes the one hazard this guide is about. Learn where the valve is and which way it turns while nothing is wrong, because it is a poor thing to search for in a hurry.
The house smells musty but everything looks fine. What now?
Open it up, get air through it, and check the places you cannot see: under sinks, behind the washer, inside the lowest kitchen cupboard, and the crawl space if the house has one. If the smell is still there after a day of ventilation, have the walls and floor read with a meter.
Can I pull up wet carpet myself?
You can lift a corner to see whether the pad beneath is soaked, and that is useful. Taking it all out before anybody has photographed it loses the evidence a claim may need, and wet carpet is extremely heavy. Lift, look, photograph, then decide with the crew what is salvageable.
Does the same advice apply after a holiday away?
Entirely. Nothing in this guide depends on an evacuation order; it depends on the house having been closed and unattended. A fortnight away in winter produces the same list of checks, and the meter test at the start is just as useful.
Sources
This guide is general information for Sutter County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.