Phones answered 24/7Yuba City, CA
Call (833) 490-5225
(833) 490-5225
Guide

Levee failures on this river, and what the water did indoors

The Shanghai Bend, Linda and Arboga levee failures, what river water does to a house once it is inside, and what the rebuilt Sutter County levees changed.

Illustration for the guide "Levee failures on this river, and what the water did indoors" (Yuba City, CA)
Short answer

Three levee failures shape how a water call is handled in this valley: Shanghai Bend on Christmas Eve 1955, Linda in February 1986 and Arboga in January 1997. This guide sets out what agencies reported about each, and what river water does to walls, floors and the space under a house once it is inside.

Key takeaways

  • A west-bank Feather River levee gave way at Shanghai Bend just after midnight on December 24, 1955, and about 90 percent of Yuba City flooded.
  • A Yuba River levee failed at Linda shortly after 6 p.m. on February 20, 1986, flooding roughly 30 square miles on the Yuba County side.
  • The Arboga levee on the Feather River failed just after 8 p.m. on January 2, 1997, and a Sutter Bypass levee near Meridian failed days later.
  • River water leaves silt and a high-water line, and the wet field inside a wall normally runs higher than the mark on the paint.
  • Porous materials that sat in flood water are generally removed rather than dried, because the contamination is in the material and not only on it.
  • Two agencies have been rebuilding these levee systems since the 2000s, and a design standard is not the same thing as a promise.

What happened at Shanghai Bend in December 1955?

A levee on the west bank of the Feather River gave way just after midnight on December 24, 1955. About 90 percent of Yuba City went under water. The death toll most often cited is 38, with sources giving 37 to 38, and nearly 40,000 people were evacuated. Marysville's levees held.

The hour matters to how the night is remembered: the break came in darkness on Christmas Eve, with a town asleep. Accounts collected since by the California State Military Museum, a regional newspaper and public reference summaries agree on the scale of the inundation and differ by one in the count of the dead, which is why both figures are given here rather than one.

Across the river, the Marysville levees did not fail, and the contrast is part of why the two counties went on to build separate flood agencies. For a household the practical legacy is simpler. The 1955 water is the reason an older building on the low ground west of the river gets read from the floor up, rather than from the stain inward.

What did the 1986 Linda failure involve?

A Yuba River levee failed at Linda shortly after 6 p.m. on February 20, 1986, and the Yuba Water Agency puts the flooded area at about 30 square miles. Evacuation estimates run from about 10,000 to 26,000 people and flooded homes from about 4,000 to 6,700. Sources differ on the number of deaths.

The spread of those estimates is not carelessness; it is what happens when a count is taken during an emergency and revised afterwards by different bodies. Where a range exists it is printed here as a range. Litigation that followed found the state responsible for the levee, as a regional newspaper has reported, and that finding is stated here as a fact of the record and left there.

Thirty square miles of standing water is a different event from a burst pipe in one kitchen, and the difference is time. Water that sits for days works into framing, into the paper facing of wallboard and into subfloor glue. The services on this site that follow from that are river flood structural drying and the extraction that has to come first.

And January 1997?

The Arboga levee on the Feather River failed just after 8 p.m. on January 2, 1997, and a Sutter Bypass levee near Meridian failed days afterward. Yuba City itself largely escaped, while the Yuba County side was hit hardest. Nearly 1,000 homes were lost or damaged; evacuee counts run from 50,000 to 100,000 by source.

That event is the one that shows most clearly how local a levee break is. A household in Arboga or Olivehurst had a very different January from a household a few miles west, and the reason is which embankment gave way rather than how much rain fell on any particular roof. Deaths are given as two or three depending on the source.

Two or three deaths statewide is not the measure of what 1997 did to the houses that took water. Nearly a thousand homes lost or damaged means a thousand sets of cabinets, ducts and subfloors, and most of those were decided not on the night of the break but in the following week, by how long the water stayed and how soon anything was opened up.

What does river water actually do to a wall?

It wicks upward. Water climbs the paper facing and gypsum core of wallboard well above the visible line, soaks any insulation in the bay, and leaves silt in the cavity at the bottom. The outside of the wall can look like a tide mark while the inside is wet a foot higher.

That is why a crew does not trust the line on the paint. A meter is run up the wall in a grid until readings drop back to normal, and the cut is made above that point rather than above the stain. Insulation behind it is pulled because soaked fiberglass holds water against framing for weeks and no longer does the one job it was installed for.

Silt is the second problem and it is the one that decides salvage. Fine sediment carried out of a riverbed settles into the gypsum core, into carpet backing and into the fibers of pad, and it cannot be rinsed out of a porous material in place. That is the reasoning behind taking those materials out instead of running fans at them for a week.

What happens to floors after a flood?

It depends on what the floor is made of and how long it stood in water. Carpet pad is almost always discarded. Laminate swells at the joints and does not come back. Hardwood cups and may be dried in place when it is caught early. Tile often survives while the bed under it stays wet.

Older homes on raised floors in Marysville, Sutter and the rural parts of the county face the harder version of this, because the water that came in over the threshold also filled the space beneath. A floor dried from above while the joists below stay soaked will read dry one week and wet the next. The crawl space has to be pumped, cleared and dried as its own compartment.

On slab-on-grade houses the question is what sits between the finish and the concrete. Glue, cork underlayment and vinyl all hold water against a slab that has itself absorbed some, and concrete gives moisture back for a long time. A reading taken at the slab surface after the finish comes up is what settles whether new flooring can go down yet.

What about the parts of the house nobody looks at?

Ductwork under a raised floor or in a slab trench, water heaters and furnaces that stood in water, electrical outlets below the line, and insulation in the floor assembly. Each is checked before anything is restarted, and mechanical equipment that was submerged is a question for the trade that installed it.

Ducts are the quiet problem. Flexible duct that filled with river water holds silt in its low points and in its lining, and a system restarted over that moves the smell of the flood through every room in the house. Opening, inspecting and in some cases replacing the affected runs is part of the cleanup rather than part of the rebuild.

Equipment is a straight boundary. A crew removes water and dries structure; a furnace, a water heater or a panel that was underwater is assessed and replaced or cleared by the trade licensed for it. Hearing that boundary described at the start of a job is a good sign. It is one of the questions set out in checking a license before work starts.

How do the three events compare on the record?

Side by side they show different embankments, different hours and very different footprints. The table below holds only what agencies and public records have reported, with ranges left as ranges where the sources disagree.

The last row is the one worth sitting with. Sutter County Public Works counts major flooding fifteen times in a hundred years across roughly 260 miles of earthen levee, which makes the three named failures episodes in a long record rather than freak events. Marysville's own answer began even earlier, with a levee commission formed in 1876 after the floods of the 1860s.

That Ring Levee now protects about 12,700 residents and took federal-standard upgrades in the 1950s, according to the Yuba Water Agency document that describes it. None of this is written to alarm anyone. It is written because a household making decisions about a wet floor is better served by the actual record than by a sales pitch.

Reported detail for three levee failures on the Feather and Yuba rivers
EventWhere and whenWhat was reported
Shanghai BendFeather River west bank, just after midnight, December 24, 1955About 90 percent of Yuba City flooded; 38 deaths most often cited, 37 to 38 by source; nearly 40,000 evacuated; Marysville levees held
LindaYuba River levee, shortly after 6 p.m., February 20, 1986About 30 square miles flooded; about 10,000 to 26,000 evacuated; about 4,000 to 6,700 homes flooded; sources differ on deaths
ArbogaFeather River levee, just after 8 p.m., January 2, 1997Yuba County side hit hardest; nearly 1,000 homes lost or damaged; 50,000 to 100,000 evacuees by source; two or three deaths by source
Meridian areaSutter Bypass levee, days after the Arboga break, January 1997A second failure in the same storm sequence; Yuba City largely escaped
Earlier recordSutter County, twentieth centuryMajor flooding 15 times, with levee breaks at Yuba City and Nicolaus in 1955, across about 260 miles of earthen levee

What has changed since the last break?

Two public agencies have been rebuilding these systems. The Sutter Butte Flood Control Agency is working on the Feather River west levee, and the Three Rivers Levee Improvement Authority on the Yuba County side. Both aim at a 200-year design standard for their urban areas, which is a standard and not a guarantee.

The Sutter Butte Flood Control Agency was formed in 2007 by Sutter and Butte counties, Yuba City, Live Oak, Gridley, Biggs and Levee Districts 1 and 9, and is repairing 44 miles of the west levee from the Thermalito Afterbay to the Sutter Bypass, mainly with slurry walls and seepage berms. Work on about 18 miles of the Sutter Bypass east levee, put at about $290 million, was still waiting on funding.

Across the river the Three Rivers Levee Improvement Authority, formed in 2004 by Yuba County and Reclamation District 784, has 29 miles of levee and setback levees on the Feather and Bear rivers behind Linda, Olivehurst, Arboga and Plumas Lake; the Yuba Water Agency and the agencies it works alongside report upwards of $600 million of levee work, including a Bear River setback levee west of Wheatland finished in 2022. If water does reach a floor despite all of it, the number to call is (833) 490-5225.

Frequently asked questions

Why do the numbers for 1986 and 1997 come as ranges?

Because the sources disagree. Evacuation and damage counts taken during an emergency are revised afterwards by different agencies and news organizations, and the revisions do not always converge. Where the record holds a spread, this page prints the spread rather than picking the figure that sounds most definite.

Did the 1955 flood reach the whole city?

About 90 percent of Yuba City was flooded after the Shanghai Bend break, which is the figure the historical accounts carry. What is not published is a reliable list of which present-day neighborhoods took water, so this site does not print one. South and downtown ground is as specific as the record supports.

Can anything soaked by river water be kept?

Non-porous things usually can. Framing, concrete, tile, glass, metal and solid wood trim can be cleaned and dried and read back to target. Carpet pad, fiberglass insulation, particleboard and the lower courses of wallboard generally cannot, because the silt and contamination are inside the material.

How long does a flooded house take to dry?

Longer than a clean-water loss of the same size, because more material has to come out before drying starts and because the slab or the crawl space has absorbed water of its own. The stage ends on a reading rather than on a date, and equipment stays until framing and subfloor reach their targets.

Does the levee work mean a house behind it is safe now?

A 200-year design standard describes how a system is engineered, not a promise about any particular building. Both agencies publish their own scopes and progress. The honest position is that the levees are far stronger than they were in 1986 and that no standard removes the need to know your own ground.

Is flood water handled differently from a sewer backup?

The steps overlap but the contamination differs. River water carries silt and field runoff; a backed-up line carries waste. Both mean porous material comes out, cleaning precedes drying and protective equipment is used. The sewage backup cleanup page covers the second case on its own.

Sources

  1. Yuba Water Agency
  2. Sutter Butte Flood Control Agency
  3. Sutter County Public Works

This guide is general information for Sutter County homeowners, not a substitute for an on-site inspection. Prices are estimates. See our disclaimer.

Need help today?

Call any hour and explain what is going on. You get a clear price before any work starts.

Keep reading

More guides

WhatsApp