Why is the stain never under the hole?
Because the attic is a sloped space over a flat ceiling, with framing, wiring and ducts in between. Water lands high, travels down a rafter or along a duct, and drips where something interrupts it. The stain marks where it finally got through the gypsum, which can be several bays away from where it entered.
This is also why a stain can come back without any new rain. If the insulation above it stayed wet and the framing was never dried, moisture keeps migrating into the same patch of board for weeks. People replace the ceiling, the mark returns, and the roof gets blamed a second time for a problem that was never dried out.
A reading settles it. Wet framing and wet board read wet; a dry historic stain reads dry. Thirty minutes in the attic with a meter tells you whether you have a live leak, an old mark, or a dried-out leak that still needs the ceiling sealed and painted.
Can wet attic insulation be saved?
Sometimes, if it was damp briefly and can be dried where it lies. Insulation that is soaked, compressed or discolored is bagged, because it holds water like a sponge, dries very slowly and does not recover its insulating value once it has been crushed by the weight of water.
Blown cellulose and fiberglass batts behave differently. Batts can occasionally be lifted, dried and put back where the wetting was light. Blown material that has clumped is finished, and trying to dry it in place means running equipment for days to save something that will insulate poorly afterwards anyway.
The call is made with a meter and by hand, not from the hatch. A crew that says the insulation is fine without going up and touching it has not checked. Equally, a crew that proposes stripping an entire attic because one bay is wet has not checked either.
What happens to the ceiling board?
It is judged on sag, on feel and on readings. Painted gypsum that is slightly damp and flat usually dries in place and is repainted. Board that has bowed, bubbled, stained through or gone soft is cut out, which also gives access to dry the cavity and to see the framing above it.
Cuts are made to a line that makes sense for the repair, usually to the framing on either side, so the patch has something to fasten to. Working to that line is worth a few extra inches of removal, because a ragged cut in the middle of a bay turns a straightforward patch into a plastering exercise.
Textured ceilings deserve a word of warning. Matching an older sprayed texture across a patch is difficult and frequently visible, so it is worth deciding at the start whether the repair will be a patch or a whole-ceiling refinish. That is a repair decision, and it is better made before the cutting than after.
- Switch off the circuit for any light or fan on the wet ceiling, at the panel
- Move furniture and stored boxes out from under the wet area
- Photograph the stain with something in shot for scale, and note the date
- Catch the drips in a container and note how fast it fills
Who comes first, the roofer or the drying crew?
In practice both, with the inside work usually starting first because wet insulation and gypsum get worse by the hour while a roof can be covered temporarily. The jobs overlap, and each needs the other's photographs: the roofer's for the opening, the drying crew's for the route the water took.
The division of labor is cleaner than it sounds. Everything above the deck is roofing; everything the water touched on the way down is restoration. Where they meet, at a wet deck or a rotten rafter, the two trades need to look at it together, because a soft deck is a roofing repair that only the inside inspection reveals.
California license classifications differ between those trades, which is worth knowing when you are hiring. Ask each contractor for a license number and check it with the Contractors State License Board license lookup. The classification that appears on records for this kind of work is C-61 / D-64 Water Damage Remediation.