Why not just dry the drywall in place?
Sometimes that is exactly what happens, where the wetting was slight and the insulation is dry. The reason it often is not possible is the cavity: there is no way to dry insulation and a plate behind a sealed wall, and gypsum that has softened or lost its surface will not recover whatever the reading says.
The test is a combination of three things: how wet the board is, whether it is still structurally sound, and what is behind it. Board that reads damp but is firm, over a cavity with no insulation and a dry plate, is a candidate for drying in place. Board that crumbles at a thumb press is not.
Where in doubt, a small inspection opening answers it in two minutes and costs almost nothing to repair. That is a much better basis for a decision than either removing a wall that could have stayed or drying one that should have come out.
How high should the cut go?
Above the highest wet reading, with a margin, and at a straight consistent height. The common practice is to cut at a level that makes the replacement board simple to fit. Cutting lower than the wet line to save material is the one choice that reliably creates problems later.
Think about what is in the wall at that height. Outlets, switches, pipes and the bottoms of window openings all influence a sensible line, and cutting just below a row of outlets is generally easier than cutting through it. A crew should be able to explain where the line is going and why before it starts.
On a two-sided wall, whether both faces come off is a separate question. Often one face is enough to dry the cavity, and keeping the other face intact saves a room's worth of decorating. Where the water came from inside the cavity or the wall is contaminated on both sides, both faces come off.
- Take the baseboard off carefully if you want to reuse it, and label it
- Photograph the tide line in each room before any cutting happens
- Empty the lower shelves and cupboards along the affected walls
- Ask where the cut line is going and what is in the wall at that height
Why is insulation nearly always replaced?
Because it holds water against the framing, dries extremely slowly inside a cavity, and loses its insulating value once it has been saturated and compressed. Even where it could technically be dried, the time and equipment needed exceed the cost of new material, and the result insulates worse.
Blown cellulose is the clearest case: once it is wet it clumps and slumps, and a cavity with slumped insulation has a cold void at the top and a dense damp mass at the bottom. Fiberglass batts occasionally survive a light wetting if they can be pulled, dried and put back, but that is the exception.
There is a timing point here too. Insulation has to come out before the drying starts, not after, because the whole purpose of opening the wall is to let air reach the framing. A cavity with wet insulation still in it and a fan pointed at it is a job that will not finish.
What does the rebuild involve?
New insulation, new board cut to the opening, tape and compound at the joints, then texture and paint to match. The finishing is where the visible quality of the job lives, and matching an existing wall texture across a patch takes more care than hanging the board did.
Decide early whether walls will be patched or repainted in full planes. Paint on a wall shows its boundaries, and a technically good patch under a different sheen is still a visible repair. Repainting whole walls, corner to corner, is usually what produces a result nobody notices afterwards.
Keep the moisture log from the drying stage even after the rebuild. It is the record showing the wall was dry when it was closed, and it is the first thing anybody will ask for if a question comes up later about a stain, a smell or a sale. Nobody can reproduce it from memory.